Scoop: As Los Angeles seeks to evict Casa la Golondrina, new owners of Olvera Street's oldest restaurant allege a shakedown
Scoop: As Los Angeles seeks to evict Casa la Golondrina, new owners of Olvera Street's oldest restaurant allege a shakedown
Gentle reader,
If you’ve visited Olvera Street lately, you likely noticed that the oldest, largest restaurant on the historic plaza is locked up tight. Casa la Golondrina Café is on the ropes. It needs our help.
The city has failed to be a good steward to this iconic legacy business, and if concerned citizens, journalists and civic leaders don’t start paying attention to what’s going on and demanding action, we fear that this core establishment at the heart of the commercial walking street will become a dead zone like Pico House, a lifeless historic building only occasionally opened up to visitors, but with no invested tenants, a place that is forgotten. The city failed to be a good steward there, too.
For this to happen to Casa la Golondrina would be a tragedy. Let’s save it instead.
What’s happening? A lot, none of it good.
Are you on social media? We’re on Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, Mastodon, Threads, Bluesky, Substack Notes, TikTok and Reddit sharing preservation news as it happens.
On Thursday, 9/14/2023 at 2pm, the Board of El Pueblo de Los Angeles Historical Monument Authority Commissioners will meet in the basement of the Biscailuz Building to discuss the eviction of the café’s tenants over outstanding rent of $242,306 and unpaid common area maintenance fees of approximately $46,000, not counting interest or late fees. [update 9/15/2023: The Los Angeles Times links to this newsletter and reports that yesterday’s eviction hearing was tabled until a future date. LA Taco and Eater LA also wrote about the situation.]
But this is not, as it appears at face value, a mere rent dispute with new operators who failed to re-open after the pandemic shutdown.
Those new operators have a lawsuit pending in Los Angeles Superior Court that raises disturbing questions about the relationship between disgraced Los Angeles City Councilman Kevin de Leon, the hospitality union UNITE HERE! Local 11, and Arturo Chavez, the General Manager of El Pueblo Historic Monument who was previously a senior staffer for fellow disgraced councilmember Gil Cedillo.
It is important to note that the story told in this legal filing is merely an allegation that has not been tested in front of a jury, nor discussed in settlement. But as it concerns the survival of a beloved woman-owned Los Angeles legacy business that will hopefully celebrate its centennial in 2024, a large establishment that is essential to the successful activation of Olvera Street, we believe the complaint merits further investigation.
Here is a link where you can read Casa Golondrina, Inc., a California Corporation, vs. The City of Los Angeles; Kevin De Leon ; UNITE HERE Local 11; and Does 1-50 (Case # 23STCV11385). This matter will next be heard at a Case Management Conference on Friday, 9/15/2023 at 8:30am in Department 48 of the Stanley Mosk Courthouse at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012 [update: this has been continued to 11/30/23].
But first, some history and context before you dive into the 268 page complaint.
Casa La Golondrina Café is the oldest restaurant on Olvera Street, located on the ground floor of Pelanconi House, the oldest brick building in Los Angeles.
Like every other public facing business in the city, La Golondrina closed in March 2020 due to the pandemic lockdown orders and has never reopened.
As we reported in late 2021, third generation owner Vivien Bonzo is seeking to transfer her interest in Golondrina to another operator. She has been trying to effect this change since 2018. But it’s not easy to do.
Olvera Street is not like any other place of business in Los Angeles. Here, due to the city’s competitive bidding rules, concession agreements are essentially restricted to families that have been vending for many years—some, like Vivien Bonzo’s, all the way back to founder Christine Sterling’s original vision for the street as a mixed-use fantasia of casual and more formal dining options, imported goods vendors, skilled artisans, antique shops, art pottery and glass, cactus nurseries, strolling musicians, puppet and live theaters, book shops, fashion retailers and apartments upstairs.
It was a creative incubator and a community hub, a place where a talented young illustrator like Leo Politi could be discovered by Script magazine publisher Rob Wagner while sketching birds and children, and launch a beautiful only-in-Los Angeles career. But by 2020, there wasn’t much variety among Olvera Street’s business owners: plenty of tacos, but not a potted cactus, belt-maker, glass-blower or bookshop to be found.
When Vivien Bonzo decided it was time to retire, a year into the lockdown, she put the word out among the qualified Olvera Street Concessionaires. Only Bertha A. and David R. Gomez, a mother/son team operating Rudy's Mexican Candy stall, expressed interest.
Because we read almost every agenda that comes out of Los Angeles City Hall, and because we love Olvera Street and revere Christine Sterling as a dogged and misunderstood preservation angel—who was not a “wealthy socialite,” as she’s typically described, but actually a struggling single mom who became obsessed with saving a place she loved—we’ve been watching this slow, now stalled, process with increasing alarm.
Naturally, we were concerned that there was a big difference between selling candy from a stand and operating a large, popular restaurant. But the Gomezes had a business plan, and could hire an experienced manager to run the show. Also, Vivien Bonzo offered to consult for a few months. So maybe it would be okay after all.
But some anonymous person or persons sure didn’t think so.
Soon after Olvera Street Space W-17a and W-17b / La Golondrina Cafe, Incorporated, LTD / Transfer of Interest hit the City Council file management system, three comments were submitted to the record.
We read a lot of written public comments. It is exceedingly unusual for one to be uploaded with nothing in the “Name” field, yet all three of these comments are nameless. All are written in a voice that suggests intimate knowledge of the place, the players and the arcane lease requirements, suggest improprieties in the Commission report and proposed transfer, accuse the new operator of trespassing and of winning an “illegal” bid, and generally appear to be making the case for a future legal challenge.
But when a suit was filed, it was by the Gomez family. Among other things, they allege that UNITE HERE Local 11, representing hospitality workers, obtained confidential information about their negotiations with El Pueblo and the City, and used it to hamper their ability to open La Golondrina.
We can’t know how much truth there is in the allegations set forth in this lawsuit. That is for a judge and jury to decide, or to be hashed out in a settlement. But these are disturbing allegations and Angelenos deserve answers. What happens on Olvera Street matters to every one of us, and it can no longer be decided in the dark, in poorly attended basement Commission hearings that are not livestreamed.
We are calling on the press and elected officials (other than the one who was named in the lawsuit) to get to the bottom of this, before it’s too late for Casa La Golondrina to reopen in time for its own centennial. Attend the Commission hearing on Thursday—go the Case Management Conference on Friday 11/30—investigate these allegations at the city level now, and not months or years from now as the case winds through the courts.
Save Casa La Golondrina! Save Olvera Street!
Update 5/15/2024: Just as legacy vendor El Burrito y La Carreta pleads for help as extended family members are displaced upon the death of their matriarch, the new operators of La Golondrina announce that they can no longer afford to fight in the courts and the restaurant is “Closed Forever.” This cannot be! The beautiful street of shops, artisans and food is dying and the city is responsible. Help!
@lagolondrina writes: It saddens us to announce that we filed for bankruptcy a few months ago. Our lawsuit against the city of LA and @mayorofla became too costly. Having spent all of our funds as well as the donated money we were unable to continue the lawsuit. We know that we had a strong winning case but unfortunately we never made it to trial. We want to thank every single person who helped us during this time. Those who spread the word, reported on us, donated and reached out to the city. Unfortunately @mayorofla office was unwilling to recognize this plumbing issue. We know this whole attempt to get us to close has been political from day one. I just wish we had the funds to continue the fight. This time Goliath beat David. We are truly sorry we did everything in our power. The whole thing has been very discouraging and eye opening to how the political system works in LA. The hardest part is that we still have our candy stand at Olvera St. and our continually reminded how they want to close the street down. Once again thank you to all our loyal customers.
yours for Los Angeles,
Kim & Richard
Esotouric
P.S. The campaign to save Marilyn Monroe’s home in Brentwood is evolving fast. so take another look at Friday’s updated newsletter to get caught up.
Psst… If you’d like to support our efforts to be the voice of places worth preserving, we have a tip jar and a subscriber edition of this newsletter, vintage Los Angeles webinars available to stream, in-person tours and a souvenir shop you can browse in. We’ve also got recommended reading bookshelves on Amazon and the Bookshop indie bookstore site. And did you know we offer private versions of our walking and bus tours for groups big or small? Or just share this link with other people who care.
UPCOMING BUS & WALKING TOURS
• Franklin Village Old Hollywood Walking Tour (Sat. 9/16) • University Park Walking Tour (Sat. 9/23) • Angelino Heights & Carroll Avenue Walking Tour (Sat. 10/7) • Eastside Babylon Crime Bus Tour (Sat. 10/14) • The Birth of Noir: James M. Cain’s Southern California Nightmare Bus Tour (Sat. 10/21) • The Real Black Dahlia Crime Bus Tour (Sat. 10/28) • Evergreen Cemetery, 1877 Walking Tour (Sun. 10/29) • The Run: Gay Downtown History Walking Tour (Sat. 11/4)
I am so relieved that you are interested in saving the real part of our overgrown and congested city. I am so impressed with your work and focus
Babs